Blog › Shipping · 6 min read

Landed Cost in Freight Bidding: Why the Lowest Quote Often Is Not

Ocean freight is one line among many. Here is how to build a comparison that survives the invoice.

The freight quote that wins on the spreadsheet and loses on the invoice is the most familiar story in import and export. It happens because the comparison is made on one line of a bill that has fifteen.

Fix the heads first

If you let each forwarder present charges their own way, you are not comparing quotes, you are comparing formats. Define the heads yourself. Every forwarder quotes into them, including zeros. There is then nothing left to add after booking.

Record the conversion rate

A USD quote converted on a calculator at whatever rate someone used that morning cannot be reproduced three months later when the variance is questioned. Capturing the rate with the bid makes the comparison auditable.

Detention and demurrage are part of the price

Free days differ by forwarder and by line. Two quotes with the same freight and different free days are not the same quote, particularly on a lane where your clearance regularly takes longer than planned.

Per container and per shipment

Some decisions are per box — how many to book. Others are per shipment — which forwarder to use. A comparison that only shows one of those views hides the other, and teams end up optimising the wrong number.

Keep lane history

The most valuable output of freight bidding is not this shipment’s saving. It is knowing, next month, what this lane actually costs. After two quarters, your enquiries start from evidence and the negotiation changes character entirely.

How do I compare freight quotes fairly?

Fix the charge heads before you ask for quotes, so every forwarder fills the same structure — freight, THC at both ends, documentation, seal, bill of lading, detention terms and destination charges. Convert currency at a rate recorded with the bid. Then compare the total, per container and per shipment.

Read more about Freight Procurement on BidBegin.

← Bidder Group Isolation: Why Not Every Bidder

See it on a live auction

Ten minutes is enough to see whether this fits how you buy or sell.

Book a demo →